The moves that matter in academic writing by gerald graff 1 everyone knows some young person who is impressively street smart but does poorly in school. You dont need to read and study the cliche pieces of literature and publications in order to gain wisdom and brain power. In hidden intellectualism by gerald graff, he emphasizes on the importance of educators helping their students discover their own intellectualism and how they can utilize it in their society. In his essay, hidden intellectualism, gerald graff asserts that although many overlook it, street smarts are as important to a person as book smarts. Hidden intellectualism gerald graffs, hidden intellectualism, is an essay where he argues about what is and should be considered intellectual. In hidden intellectualism, by gerald graff, he states. In the article graff critiques the approach schools take towards teaching literature. Jan 28, 20 thus their hidden intellectualism is never brought to surface. I was your typical teenage antiintellectualor so i believed for a long time.
Professionals and what impressions they get from television the four articles listed below all have the common theme of television, though some believe that tv has gone too far, others say that tv has actually made the generation smarter. In the aspect to having the smarts that the school considers to be actual intellect, which would be the book intellect in terms of what the kids are supposed to learn, there are also things that would be overlooked by the education system. In his essay, graff argues that street smarts have intellectual potential. In the article graff draws attention to the many types and ways different people can identify with intellectualism. Hidden intellectualism gerald graff rhetorical analysis essay. He believes that street smarts are incorrectly regarded as unintellectual when it comes to education.
Hidden intellectualism gerald graff s, hidden intellectualism, is an essay where he argues about what is and should be considered intellectual. In hidden intellectualism, graff uses his childhood to back up his point. Hidden intellectualism gerald graff thesis proposal. I read an essay by gerald graff entitled hidden intellectualism the main concept behind the piece is to suggest that intellectualism, a word often connoted with academics, is not a facility which can only be achieved through proper education, namely school, college, and reading a list of dullapproved books and drudging through piles of work. Argument analysis 2 hidden intellectualism of the essays we have read to date this has been on of my favorites. Summaryresponse for hidden intellectualism draft 1 o. Warners account of the buried continuity between his pentecostal past and his academic intellectual present made me rethink the way i tend to charactergra. Hidden intellectualism reflection essay write2dream. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our privacy policy. Blue collar brilliance and hidden intellectualism 123. Graff argues that an individuals personality, life experience, how they were raised, where they grew up and the extent of their formal education shapes the way they. Gerald graff s hidden intellectualism 890 words 4 pages. Graff uses his own experiences in his childhood to help form his argument.
Feb 20, 2014 graff, believing fullheartedly in this idea, created a lesson plan with an eleventh grade high school english teacher to make students familiar with intellectualism through exercises like debates on the pros and cons of becoming an intellectual and discussing the hidden intellectualism of the main characters in literary works such as. Someone who argues for this fact is gerald graff who wrote the essay hidden intellectualism gerald argues that many educators and other people do not take advantage of students full potential, stating that there is intellect far beyond academic skills, intellectualism can also be found in street smarts 382 thorough out the essay. To outline his thesis, graff uses a negative comment right away in the introduction what a waste, we think, that one who is so intelligent about so many things in life seems unable. Gerald graff, hidden intellectualism while reading gerald graff s essay, hidden intellectualism. Graff s assertion that intellectualism can be developed and sharpened in a context outside of what we consider to be solely academic is a claim that is reasonably made and that has the potential to encourage a greater number of students to think critically. In the article hidden intellectualism author gerald graff uses naysayers to support his argument that intellect is not just defined by academics. Nov 03, 2015 hidden intellectualism most likely refers to people who are seemingly bereft of any traits that exhibit intelligence, but show it in subtle ways that are unexpected and planned. Hidden intellectualism by gerald graff super emerging. He further advances this type of intellectualism is hidden within the mask of usual discussions about fashion, sports, popstars and lots of other aspects dana. Graff has a very strong voice and many opinions to help further his arguments. He believes that academic intelligence can be important, but students have things called interests as well, whether. Hughes is short and to the point and is simply what it is, no arguing or convincing.
Asserting that these street smarts go untapped by formal schooling, graff states that students interests are identified as antiintellectual and teachers ignore the potential that lays in students discourse about areas of interest them. Pop culture subjects can help students develop academic principles. Mla citation fact and definition cause and effect value action jurisdiction source 1 graff, gerald. Gerald graff born 1937 is a professor of english and education at the university of illinois at chicago.
Graff explains that schoolsmarts can be hidden within street smarts and can be learnt through not just talking with friends, but also from the media and our surroundings, hence the hidden intellectualism. I have recently come to think, however, that my preference for sports over schoolwork was not anti intellectualism so much as intellectualism by other means. Gerald graff argues that our schools and colleges make the intellectual life seem more opaque, narrowly specialized, and beyond normal learning capacities. In the article hidden intellectualism, graff contends that there is a plausibility of some concealed intellectualism other than the traditional scholastic intellectualism. Hidden intellectualism by gerald graff by crystal houston.
They continue to state that this type of intellectualism is disguised in under the cover of common talks about design, sports. Hidden intellectualism pedagogy duke university press. Reflection on gerald graffs, hidden intellectualism. Graff insists that knowledge can also take the form of street smarts. Gerald graff makes in his article hidden intellectualism, where graff attempts to convince teachers to broaden the scope of school curriculum to accommodate street smarts and more popular topics. Professor of english and education university of illinois at chicago president, modern language association 2008. Lauren mason moved read hidden intellectualism by gerald graff from week 3 to week 2. There are several connections that can be linked to the phrase hidden intellectualism. They continue to state that this type of intellectualism is disguised in under the cover of common talks about design, sports, popstars and numerous different viewpoints. Hidden intellectualism, by gerald graff 78 words 123.
In his article hidden intellectualism, gerald graff criticizes those that do not put value into street smarts. Oct 14, 2015 hidden intellectualism by gerald graff posted on october 14, 2015 by kltibbs1 in the passage, hidden intellectualism from the book they sayi say, gerald graff talks to us about how street smarts and academic work could go hand in hand. Read hidden intellectualism by gerald graff on welcome to. Read hidden intellectualism by gerald graff on welcome. Introduction to writing in college the writing process read shitty first drafts and prewriting.
Graff absolutely hated the thought of reading a book, and now he is a very successful man. Jan 28, 2011 gerald graffs essay, hidden intellectualism, argues for the convergence of street smarts of students and the school classroom. He also elaborated on his own experiences in revealing his hidden intellectualism, while. Summary of graffs hidden intellectualism studymoose. Hidden intellectualism by gerald graff 723 words 3 pages hidden intellectualism written by gerald graff, is a compelling essay that presents the contradicting sides of book smarts and street smarts and how these terms tied in to graffs life growing up. They are so focused on academic intelligence that they completely ignore the values of being street smart.
Hidden intellectualism they say i say free pdf file sharing. Hidden intellectualism, by gerald graff essay 85 words. Growing up in chicago postworld war ii, graff was all too aware of the class. In the essay hidden intellectualism by gerald graff, many points are argued. Summary of gerald graffs hidden intellectualism essay. Hidden intellectualism hidden intellectualismanalysis of. He learned how to make arguments,generalizations, weigh different kinds of evidence from just watching television and reading magazines. Books written and edited by gerald graff gerald graff. Reflection on gerald graff s, hidden intellectualism street smarts or school smarts. That seems to be the question of graff s essay, and he goes in depth about it and how the two relate. Lauren mason renamed read hidden intellectualism by gerald graff from read freewriting by peter elbow and respond to the three discussion questions on your journal. Hidden intellectualism in gerald graffs hidden intellectualism, graff argues that by not involving nonacademic elements to the curriculum, schools are missing out on opportunities to encourage their students to learn.
As graff describes, he felt the need to prove i was smart and the fear of a. Oct, 2015 reflection on gerald graffs, hidden intellectualism street smarts or school smarts. Sep 30, 2012 in the article hidden intellectualism author gerald graff uses naysayers to support his argument that intellect is not just defined by academics. Gerald graff takes the classic school smarts versus street smarts argument and presents it in a way that may not have occured to us before now. Hidden intellectualism, by gerald graff essay 85 words cram. Hidden intellectualism an excerpt from they sayi say. Feb 01, 2014 graff, believing hullheartedly in this idea, made a lesson plan with an eleventh grade english teacher to make students familiar with intellectuals through exercises like debates on pros and cons of becoming an intellectual and discussing the hidden intellectualism of the main characters in adventures of huckleberry finn by mark twain and the. Graff does this by including his own personal experience as a child and correlates it to his argument to prove his point. The article hidden intellectualism by gerald graff is adapted from his 2003 book clueless in academe. Nov 30, 2016 in the article hidden intellectualism, graff contends that there is a plausibility of some concealed intellectualism other than the traditional scholastic intellectualism. Hidden intellectualism summary in gerald graff s hidden intellectualism, graff attests that intellect does not only exist in the scholarly form of thinking.
Hidden intellectualism analysis of the essay hidden intellectualism by gerald graff critical reading step 2 in his essay, hidden intellectualism, gerald graff argues that the education system is flawed and doesnt focus on real life and how a person that was truly intellectual has an ability to look at a situation with academic eyes. He primarily focused on the way adolescents view intellectualism as a negative trait that only nerds strive for. He further advances this type of intellectualism is hidden within the mask of usual discussions about fashion, sports. Graff insists that knowledge goes far beyond academic learning and continues into the everyday world. Hidden intellectualism, gerald graff essay 418 words. Hidden intellectualism is about the connection between the informal way of learning and the formal way of education. Essay example on the topic of hidden intellectualism. A simple gem of wisdom, yet one that remains hidden beneath a sea of academic tradition. There is a different form of intellectualism besides the traditional academic intellectual thought. As a child, graff always looked for a happy medium between brawn and brain. Such subjects often use academic principles for developing arguments and presenting material. According to the two scholars, the education curriculum drills students in respect to their careers forcing their mind to become dumb. Hidden intellectualism in geralds graff essay hidden intellectualism, gerald argues that many educators and other people do not take advantage of students full potential, stating that there is intellect far beyond academic skills, intellectualism can also be found in street smarts. Hidden intellectualism, by gerald graff, is an essay in which the former english professor discusses the misconceptions of the ideas of intellectualism amongst society.
Gerald graff and michiko kakutani address the issue of dumbness in the current education system, which leads to the production of halfbaked professionals. In a simple way, it turns to be a question of street smarts vs. In hidden intellectualism, gerald graff pens an impressive argument wrought from personal experience, wisdom and heart. Graff s purpose in writing this article is to explain issues within the educational system as a whole. Hidden intellectualism gerald graff rhetorical analysis. In graff s essay, hidden intellectualism, he goes over the intellectuallism. Jan 23, 2014 response to gerald graffs, hidden intellectualism january 23, 2014 1 comment quote. In hidden intellectualism by gerald graff, he begins with the argument of streetsmarts versus schoolsmarts. Tone logos the tone of this article sounds as if he is trying to serve a purpose. Hidden intellectualism gerald graff il, ev e ryo n e i gerald graff s hidden intellectualism analysis. Response to gerald graff s hidden intellectualism when first reading gerald graff s essay, hidden intellectualism, i thought his thesis was this, what doesnt occur to us, though, is that schools and colleges might be at fault for missing the opportunity to tap into such street smarts and channel them into good academic work. He has taught at the university of new mexico, northwestern university, the university of california at irvine and at berkeley, as well. Within the essay hidden intellectualism, gerald graff argues that theres possible of some type of hidden intellectualism aside from the traditional academic intellectualism.
Gerald graffs hidden intellectualism essay 1644 words. Main purpose argument purpose the authors purpose is to shed light onto a possibly flawed schooling system. Sep 12, 2016 graffs assertion that intellectualism can be developed and sharpened in a context outside of what we consider to be solely academic is a claim that is reasonably made and that has the potential to encourage a greater number of students to think critically. Educational prestige as a longterm english professor personal testimony of childhood experience using himself as a case in point, in one way, then graff claims, it. Graff uses ethos here by relating his argument of streetsmart intellectualism to his own adolescent experience. With the ever changing world that we live in, author gerald graff writes in his article hidden intellectualism, that society needs to think more about what happens in the future in our schools, so we need to teach more subjects concerning street smarts in our schools. I agree with graffs assumption that readings are important to analyze and understand in order to make a valid argument and respond to counterarguements, because, although this thought process is challenging, it is rewarding in the long run, as it goes beyond debates and into.
Former modern language association president 2008, prominent education theorist, and ace founding adviser, gerald graff, tells a story in his essay hidden intellectualism of how he learned to be an intellectual not in school, which he really didnt like, but by arguing about sports especially baseball, especially the cubs with his friends. Langston hughes theme for english b and gerald graffs essay hidden intellectualism portray racial separation and intellectual isolation, respectively. Response to hidden intellectualism by gerald graff. Teaching the club 11 hidden intellectualism 211 12 a word for words and a vote for quotes 232 wrestling with the devil 246 14 deborah meiers progressive traditionalism 261. Final paper of hidden intellectualism summaryresponse. Jun 18, 2012 hidden intellectualism, in my perspective is about how students challenging writing.
Sep 03, 2015 in the essay hidden intellectualism by gerald graff, many points are argued. Feb 09, 2014 in graffs essay, hidden intellectualism, he goes over the intellectuallism. Hidden intellectualism hidden intellectualism hidden. In hidden intellectualism, gerald graff talks about how educators are going about the wrong way in doing their job. Hidden intellectualism by graff academic writers bureau. He demonstrates that while some people come across as very street smart, with knowledge on a variety of subjects, they do poorly in school and seem like they are not smart.
He argues that people are intelligent in several ways. That seems to be the question of graffs essay, and he goes in depth about it and how the two relate. I read an essay by gerald graff entitled hidden intellectualism the main concept behind the piece is to suggest that intellectualism, a word often connoted with academics, is not a facility which can only be achieved through proper education, namely school, college, and reading a list of dullapproved books and. I say by gerald graff, cathy birkenstein, and russel durst. Hidden intellectualism by gerald graff 723 words 3 pages hidden intellectualism written by gerald graff, is a compelling essay that presents the contradicting sides of book smarts and street smarts and how these terms tied in to graff s life growing up. In the article hidden intellectualism written by gerald graff, graff target college students to inform them about a hidden intellectualism that can be found in our everyday society. Hidden intellectualism in his article hidden intellectualism, gerald graff criticizes those that do not put value into street smarts. A response to hidden intellectualism abigail bashor. Hidden intellectualism tone larger conversations purpose the author seems to display a certain frustration with how he was taught to be in school, and how that educational system still hinders the potential of young people to explore their own intellectuality. What a waste, we think, that one who is so intelligent about so many things in life seems unable to apply that intelligence to. There must be many buried or hidden forms of intellectualism that do not get channeled into academic work but might if schools were more alert about tapping into them.